A few nights ago I played bass for a gig using my laptop and MIDI controller. Playing the infamous ‘left handed bass’ can be somewhat problematic, as keyboard bass doesn’t always have the same rhythmic ‘punch’ as a real bass guitar going through a real bass amp. Also worth pointing out is that we’re not the sort of band suited to a synthy bass sound (we like Roy Orbison, Zombies, Beach Boys, etc).
In consideration of these factors, I spent a good bit of time designing a synth patch in Logic that would produce a convincing bass response without sounding too canned or preset-y. Bass guitar samples almost always have a robotic feel to them, which can be good depending on what you’re going for, but in our case we needed something that would at least hint at real live steel strings.
The result was surprisingly effective - even though I was playing through the PA, people in the crowd said it sounded like a real bass amp. To help any potentially bassless wanderers coming to this site, I’ll break down what I did using only Logic’s onboard inserts. This is by no means a definitive guide to bass-faking - I also don’t know how well this setup would translate to a ‘real’ venue (we played a small art gallery with terrible acoustics). Still, for smaller gigs, this may come in handy if you find yourself in a bassless jam (forgive the pun).
How to get decent bass guitar emulation in Logic:
My setup is: Logic 8 on a white mid 2008 macbook with an Akai MPK49 controller. I got the Akai used off of ebay, and its condition on the damage scale falls somewhere between ‘moderate’ and ‘Keith Emerson’s Organ.’ Two of the keys are held down with electrical tape, a lot of switches need to be pressed aggressively to work, and plugging an expression pedal in produces squealingly erratic behaviour. Still, the keys as well as the fader/knob banks are fine. I also regularly dust and Lysol the unit, which seems to keep it free of the ‘ghosting’ issues other users have talked about.
For the bass sound itself, I used the ES2 synthesizer with a pretty simple setup - no routing, all oscillators just set to sine waves. The second oscillator was an octave up, the other two were the same octave. Two sine waves of the same pitch gave it some added thickness, and the octave provided made everything clearer and less muddy. Although the instrument only gives the output option of Stereo or 5.1, the signal output is essentially monophonic unless you have the ‘Unison’ switch selected, (or if you’re routing or vectoring any pan functions).
Side note: If you’re unfamiliar with the workings of the ES2, I highly recommend Terryguide’s 12-part video tutorial on using the instrument (it's free!). The instrument's not bad for bare-bones modular synthesis, and it's just generally fun to play around with
On the Akai, I assigned one fader to control the main level, and two to control Attack and Release settings. The release control in particular came in handy for passages that demanded a more plucky, staccato sound. I also assigned one knob to control switching between monophonic and polyphonic modes. I should note that I don’t have a sustain pedal (I know, I know), hence the need for this extra programming.
In the channel strip inserts, I used the built-in ‘Bass Amp’ plugin, with the model set to “Top Class DI Warm” It made a noticeable difference in terms of making the ES2 sound more like a bass and less like a synthesizer, particularly in terms of dynamics and low/mid balance. A few tweaks to the gain and midrange were all that were needed to get it in shape.
I hope this was helpful. Give me a shout if you know of any ways to improve on this.
This is awesome! Really enjoying reading these, DP.
ReplyDelete